Humboldt State University ® Department of Chemistry

Robert A. Paselk Scientific Instrument Museum

 
From: Clay, Reginald S. Treatise on Practical Light. Macmillan and Co., Limited. London (1911) pp 449-59.
 
©Richard A. Paselk 1998

 
 
 
CHAPTER XXI
 
POLARISED LIGHT
 
Experiments on the Polarisation of Light.
 
349. Apparatus. - The polariscope used in the following experiments may be easily made of wood. To a base board about 6 inches square, attach two uprights, each about 12 inches high and 3/8 inch by 1 inch section. On the top of these fasten a stage, EF, also 6 inches square, having a hole 1/2 inch in diameter at its centre. About 6 inches from the top, fix a horizontal glass plate, D, to act as a platform, and at about 4 inches from the bottom hinge another glass plate, A, about 5 inches square. An ordinary silvered mirror, B, about 4 or 5 inches square is placed on the bottom; and a piece of zinc, Z, is bent round partly to inclose the space between the platform at the top and the glass stage. The zinc may be attached to the stand by a sort of bayonet joint, P, so that it can easily be removed. Cut a hole about 3 inches in diameter in the thin piece of wood 6 inches square, and fasten this to the top of the table, EF. The glass plate, A, can easily be hinged by inserting it in saw cuts made in small wooden blocks as indicated in Fig. 365. Cut a black card to lie on the glass

 

 450

 TREATISE ON PRACTICAL LIGHT
 

 stage, D, with a hole 1/4 inch in diameter vertically under the hole in the top board. Draw lines on the top stage, EF, parallel to the sides, which would, if produced, pass through the centre of the circles, and also lines bisecting the angles between these, so as to mark every 45°.
 
Fitting easily in the 3 inch circle of the platform, EF, make three wooden discs each with a 1/2 inch hole through its centre, of the same thickness as the board in which the 3 inch hole was made. To one of these, El Fl, (Fig. 366), attach two uprights, and hinge between them in the same way as before, a small mirror, C (Fig. 366), about 1 inch by 1 1/2 inches, either of black glass, or of glass blackened at the back, with the reflecting surface downwards. Oil another disc, E2 F2, between two similar
uprights, support a " pile of plates," T, of micro-cover glass at an angle of about 53°. The glasses used by botanists, about 2 inches by 1 inch, answer perfectly for this purpose. To the third E3 F3, attach a short tube which just fits a small nicol's N - one of those sold for attachment to the microscope is sufficiently large.
 
In addition to the polariscope, two rhombs of Iceland spar of about 1/2 inch side, a second nicol, and a pair of tourmalines will be required; protractor, piece of spar cut perpendicular to the axis mounted in cork ; tinfoil ; two sewing needles stuck into a wood block with their points outwards and in the same vertical line.
 
35O. Use of Polariscope.-(a) Set up the polariscope in front of window so that the light from the skyl shall be-
 
1. Reflected vertically down from the inclined glass plate, AA (Fig. 367).
 
2. Reflected vertically up from the silvered mirror, B.
 
l At night a sheet of white card may be set up in front of the instrument, with good light illuminating it.
 

 

 POLARISED LIGHT

 451


3. Partly transmitted by the glass plate, AA.
NOTE.- Nearly all the light is returned by the plate to the sky, but a small portion is transmitted.
 
4. Reflected by the black glass plate, C, into the eye.
 
(b) Without otherwise moving anything rotate the top black glass round a vertical axis, and observe the effect on the light.
 
In two positions the light will be nearly extinguished, and in two positions it will have maximum brightness.
 
Draw a diagram to indicate clearly the two positions in which it is dark, and the two in which it is bright.
 
Definition.- If plane polarised light be incident at the angle of polarisation on a glass surface (and the plane of incidence be varied by rotating the glass while the angle of incidence be kept the same), the plane of incidence in which the light is best reflected is the plane of polarisation of the incident light.
 
351. Plane of Polarisation. - (a) Examine the light transmitted by the plate A, and using the above definition, find its plane of polarisation. Also state, with reasons, whether the polarisation produced by the plate A was produced by (1) the reflection down to B, or (2) the transmission through A.
 
(b) Replace the black glass mirror, C, by the pile of plates, draw diagrams as in Experiment 350, and compare them with those obtained in that experiment.
 
Show that the planes of polarisation of reflected and transmitted light are at right angles.
 
352. Brewster's Law. - Replace the black glass mirror, and turn
it to extinction. Now without rotating its plane alter its inclination, and that of the plate A, until the centre of the field is quite dark, and thus endeavour to find the angle of polarisation. Measure this angle with a protractor; and using the formula given by Brewster:
 
tan i =u ,
 
find the refractive index of the glass.
 

 452

 TREATISE ON PRACTICAL LIGHT
 

353- Double Refraction. - (a) Examine the small rhomb of Iceland spar- there are eight angular points; see that at six of these corners, there are two acute and one obtuse angle, but at the other two, which are diagonally opposite one another, there are three obtuse angles. If the rhomb has all its edges equal the line joining these two points is the optic axis of the crystal. Draw the crystal.
 
(b) Make a small black dot on a piece of paper, and place one of the rhombs upon it. You will see two dots. Draw a diagram of the crystal as seen from above, inserting in the drawing, the optic axis, and the line joining the
dots. Notice carefully the relation of these two lines.
 
(c) Rotate the crystal and draw a diagram of the appearance every 90°. Which dot moves?
 
(d) Raise the rhomb gradually from the paper, and notice carefully any change in position of the dots. Does their distance apart alter? Hence show by diagrams in a vertical plane the course of the rays to the eye.
 
(e) Set up the block with the two needles so that their points are vertically over a black dot on a piece of paper (Fig. 369). Place the rhomb over the dot, and using the needles as a guide, observe which of the two dots coincides with the original dot. The dot that coincides is called the one
formed by the ordinary ray, and the other is formed by the extraordinary ray.
 
(f) See that it is the ordinary ray that remains still when the crystal is rotated.
 
(g) Look carefully at the apparent positions of the two dots in
 

 

 POLARISED LIGHT

 453


the crystal. One will be seen to be higher than the other. Which is it? Hence which refractive index is the greater-that of the ordinary ray or that of the extraordinary ray?
 
354. i. Polarisation by Double Refractiou.- (a) Make a pin-hole in a piece of tinfoil, and lay it on the stage of the polariscope (Fig 365). Place a spar rhomb on it, and looking directly down through the hole in the top stage, observe the effect of rotating the rhomb. Hence show that the light of each dot is polarised. Which ray is polarised in the plane containing the two dots?
 
(b) Place the rhomb on a black dot on a piece of white paper, and examine with the "pile of plates" the two dots produced. Remembering the plane of polarisation of the transmitted light, see whether your results agree with those obtained by the last method.
 
(c) Place a second rhomb over the first, and draw diagrams of the appearance of the dots at every rotation of 45° of the upper rhomb. In particular explain the positions of the two dots in each of the four positions in which only two are left.
 
(d) Test your explanation by examining these two dots with the pile of plates.
 
ii. The optic Axis. - Place the piece of spar cut at right angles to the optic axis, on a black dot or a pin-hole in tinfoil, and see that it does not divide the light into two. Test the light and see if it is polarised.
 
iii. Nicols Prism. - (a) Place the nicol's prism on the upper stage of the polariscope, and find the plane of polarisation of the light it transmits. Is it along the line AB?
 
(b) See that two nicols produce more complete extinction than can be got with the reflecting polariscope.
 
355. Tourmalines. - Examine the pair of tourmalines. Set them to allow the light to pass, and examine it with a nicol. See that it is plane polarised. Note that the light they transmit is coloured. (Hence for most purposes they are inferior to a nicol.) See that they produce very complete extinction.
 

 454

 TREATISE ON PRACTICAL LIGHT
 

Colours of Thin Plates.
 
356. Apparatus. - Polariscope; mica and selenite films; double.image prism; Fox's wedge.
 
i. Mica and Selenite Plates. - (a) Set up the polariscope with a nicol as analyser (i.e. in place of the pile of plates or the mirror C), and arrange it to extinguish the light. Also tilt the glass reflector, A, till the extinction is as complete as possible.
 
(b) Place a thin piece of mica or selenite on the stage, and note that colour is produced.
 
(c) Rotate the mica and see that in four positions at right angles it has no effect. In each of these four positions, rotate the nicol, and see that the effect is precisely the same as if the mica were not present.
 
(d) Place the nicol once more to extinction, and rotate the mica - note that the colour is brightest at angles half-way between the positions at which it has no effect.
 
(e) Leave the mica in the position in which it has the greatest effect and rotate the nicol. Notice that when it is turned 45° the mica once more has no effect; on rotating another 45° the colour is again bright, but is the complementary of what it was at first.
 
ii. Double Image Prism. - (a) Replace the nicol by the double image prism and see that the separate half images vary in the same way as those produced above, also that they are always complementary, and therefore where they overlap they form white. Note that the actual tint of the halves changes suddenly to its complementary, and that till that change they only vary by having more or less white mixed with them.
 
(b) Replace the mica by other pieces and note that the colour depends on the thickness.
 

 

 POLARISED LIGHT

 455


iii. Fox wedge. - Place the Fox wedge on the stage and note the colour changes. See that the colours pro-
duced proceed as in Newton's rings, and that in this wedge there are two orders of colour. (The wedges are made by cementing equal thicknesses of mica together so as to form a flight of steps each rising by an equal amount, see p. 461, Exercise 4....)
 
357. In all the above cases plane polarised light falls on the crystal (mica) and is, in general, at once split into two beams, polarised in planes at right angles to one another, which may, or may not be of equal intensity. These two rays travel through the crystal with different velocities, and, reaching the other side, have therefore gained or lost some fraction of a wave-length on one another. Here they recombine.
 
If either of the planes of polarisation of the light in the crystal happens to coincide with the plane of polarisation of the incident light, of course there will be only one ray in the crystal. In this case, there can be no interference, whatever the thickness of the crystal. Hence, in four positions at right angles, the crystal has no effect as in Experiment 356, i. (c).
 
If the plane of the incident light bisects the angle between the planes of polarisation of the light in the crystal, as in Fig. 374, the two rays will
be of equal intensity. In this case,
the interference effects will be most marked; for should one ray of any colour gain half a wavelength, that colour will interfere completely.
 
If one ray gains any whole number of wave-lengths of any colour over the other ray, that colour will emerge in the same relative phase as it entered, and will combine therefore into a vibration in the same plane. So that, if the nicol is crossed, that is, if it is arranged for extinction, that colour will remain dark: or, if the field had been bright, that colour will remain bright.
 

 456

 TREATISE ON PRACTICAL LIGHT
 

If one ray, gains an odd number of half wave-lengtlis over the other for any colour, then suppose OA (Fig. 375) to be the incident vibration; on entry it is resolved into two components at right angles, OP and OQ. On emergence, if we suppose one component vibration to be in the same phase as at entry, to be, for instance, at Q' (Fig. 376), the other must be in the opposite phase to the one at entry; it will thus be at the other end of its swing at P'. The resultant of the component displacements OQ' and OP' will be the displacement OB. Also, as the component displacements at emergence will be along OQ' and OP', and will be equal in amount to those at incidence along OQ and OP the resultant displacement will be always be along OB. That is, it is still plane polarised, but in a different plane. If, in addition, the angle AOP (Fig. 375) is 45°, it will be polarised in a plane at right angles, since the [angle] A'OB is double the [angle] A'OQ'. Therefore, in a dark field, this colour (being rotated 90°) will appear bright, and dark in a bright field. Thus, we
see the colour depends on the thickness and why it changes to its complementary on rotating the analyser through a right angle.
 
If one ray gains 1/4 wave-length on the other for some colour, then Q will be in the middle of its swing when P is at the end of its swing, and vice versa. Hence, as they are at right angles and of equal amplitude, the resultant will be a circular vibration (Fig- 377). The colour will therefore appear equally bright with all positions of the analyser. This is called circularly polarised light. (This can only be true, of course, for one colour at a time, and should be therefore
 

 

 POLARISED LIGHT

 457


observed with a sodium flame. A film of mica of such a thickness that it produces this effect is called a Quarter Wave Plate.
 
If the gain is no exact wavelength, 1/2 wave-length, or 1/4 wave-length, the emergent light will have an elliptic vibration, and will be called elliptically polarized light. Such a colour will increase and fade as the nicol is rotated, but in no position can it be completely extinguished.
 
If the gain were 1/4 wavelength, but the axes in the mica were not at 45° with the plane of the incident light, the amplitudes of the two rays OP, and OQ, would be unequal (Fig. 378). The effect would again be that the vibrations of the emergent light would be elliptic and not circular.
 
358. i. Norremberg Doubler. - Place the mica film (Experiment 356, i.) on the mirror B. The colour will in general be quite different. The light now has to pass twice through the mica, and, therefore, as the ray which travelled most slowly on going down will again travel most slowly after reflection, it will lose twice as much as it would do were the mica ol the stage D. The effect is thus the same as if a film of double thickness had been placed on D.
 
This form of polariscope is often called the Norremberg "doubler" in consequence of this action.
 
ii. Quarter Wave Plate. - (a) Examine a quarter wave plate of mica on the stage D (Fig. 365), using a sodium flame. On rotating the analyser see that the intensity remains unchanged. {The mica must have its axes at 45° with the plane of polarisation.}
 
(b) Place the quarter wave plate on B, and see that it is bright in a dark field, and dark in a bright one, i.e. it acts as a half wave plate.
 
iii. Half Wave Plate. - (a) Place a half wave plate (i.e. a film of mica of a thikness that delays one component of the light half a period) on D, and see that it behaves as ii. (b).
 
(b) Place it on B and note the effects.
 
iv. Cause of Difference of Phase. - (a) Take a small piece of mica of uniform thickness and scratch a line on it parallel to the direction in which it has no effect, cut it in two along some line
 
 

 458

 TREATISE ON PRACTICAL LIGHT
 

(such as the dotted one). Place the pieces on one another with the scratch on each parallel and place it at 45° as usual. Note the colour when on D (in white light). Now place a single piece on B and see that you get the same colour.
 
(b) Take the same two pieces, but this time place them so that the scratch on one is perpendicular to the scratch on the other. Place the pair on either stage and see that it has no effect on the light in any position. Explain this.
 
To produce the Polarisation of Light with a Plate of Spar cut normally to the Axis, using the difference between the Critical Angles of the Ordinary and Extraordinary Rays.
 
359. Apparatus. - A plate of Iceland spar cut perpendicular to the axis as large and as thin as can be obtained; a glass trough with parallel
sides at sufficient distance apart to allow the spar to be placed obliquely between them;l carbon bisulphide or some alpha-mono-bromo-napthalene; a nicol or double-image prism.
 
Theory. - The refractive index of spar is given in the following table:
 

 Rays
Extraordinary
Ray.
 Ordinary
Ray.

A.

1.4828

1.6501

C.

1.4847

1.6545

D.

1.4864

1.6585

F.

1.4908

1.6679

G.

1.4945

1.6762
 
 
l In place of the trough a glass beaker, or better, a tube:with a plain glass bottom, may be set up with its axis vertical, and the spar placed in this at the angle of 20° with this veriical axis, and then the carbon bisulphide poured in until its surface is above the spar; it will be found that the light coming up vertically through the spar is polarised.
 
 

 

 POLARISED LIGHT

 459


The refractive index of alpha-mono-bromo-naphthalene at 20° C, for the D line is 1.6582, which is almost identical with the refractive index of the ordinary ray in spar. Thus the critical angle for the ordinary ray is 90° and for the extraordinary ray is about 64° (p. 28). The refractive index of carbon bisulphide is 1.67, and the critical angles are 83° and 62° respectively for yellow light.
 
Experiment. - If, therefore, the spar is placed in the cell with its plane vertical, and making an angle of about 70° with the face of the trough, and if the trough is filled with either of these liquids, the light from a distant source falling upon the surface of the glass normally will enter
the liquid, and when it reaches the surface of the spar the extraordinary ray will strike the surface at an angle greater than the critical angle, and therefore will be entirely reflected. The ordinary ray will pass almost straight through it, as the refractive index of the ordinary ray in the spar is nearly the same as that in the liquid.
 
Examine each of the beams, the transmitted and reflected, with a nicol, and see that they are polarised in planes perpendicular to one another, the ordinary ray being polarised in the principal plane, which is the plane of incidence, since the optic axis coincides with the normal.
 
Jamin suggested this arrangement as a polarising apparatus (instead of the nicol's prism), but liquid prisms are awkward to use. Feussner made one of glass and spar (Nature, March 27, 1884), but as he was unable to find a cement of sufficiently high refractive index the prism was not very successful. The reflected beam will only be perfectly polarised if the refractive index is absolutely identical in the spar and the liquid.
 
 

 

Index of Instruments

Museum Home

Instrument Literature

 

 
HSTC (1921-34)
HSC (1935-1953)
HSC (1954-1973)
© R. Paselk
Last modified 22 July 2000